The Prisoner “Fall Out” Theory
By Kirby, with Contributions from Reed and Kent
1996 Reed, Kent, and Kirby Meyer. Last Modified: 25 October 2021.
(Much
of
this
can
be
found
through
the
Troyer
Interview
and
other
websites.)
The
first
sixteen
have
some
sort
of
pragmatic
functionality
about
them,
prompting
the
show
to
be
treated
as
a
science-fiction
series
(as
evident
by
being
shown
on
the
Sci-Fi
Channel
back
in
the
90s).
It
is
in
my
opinion
an
error
to
give
“Fall
Out”
that
same
treatment.
Rejecting
“Fall
Out”
as
a
science
fiction
story
is
crucial
to
understanding
the
theory
I'm
about
to
present.
At
this
point,
only
accept
the
idea
that
the
final
episode
continues
on
with
the
same
characters
and
attempts
to
wrap
up
holes
left
from
the
first
sixteen
episodes.
Or,
if
I
may
indulge,
merely
accept
“Fall
Out”
as
a
philosophical
soapbox
for
Patrick
McGoohan,
who
now
had
creative
freedom
over
the
show
since
Markstein had left.
•
George Markstein left the series by this time due to creative differences with McGoohan.
•
McGoohan wrote the script for “Fall Out” within 48 hours of the shooting deadline.
•
It is heavy enriched with symbolic devices.
•
The first airing of “Fall Out” caused mass confusion in England and abroad.
Before
I
discuss
my
interpretation
of
the
episode
“Fall
Out”
it
is
important
to
first
note
there
is
a
distinction
between
the
first
sixteen
episodes
and
this
final
story.
It
can
be
supported by several facts:
Now,
I
begin.
“Fall
Out”,
somewhat
like
its
predecessors,
has
its
place
with
the
Sixties'
Peace
Revolution
and
the
Cold
War.
I
make
note
that
the
first
sixteen
episodes
share
some
common
ground
with
the
final
episode
regarding
the
Orwellian
term
“Big
Brother.”
However,
rather
than
drum
into
our
heads
that
a
pragmatic
unconnectable
entity
--
the
Village
--
is
watching
us,
McGoohan
attempts
to
move
things
back
into
the
real
world
(note
the
A20
road
at
the
end
of
the
story).
So,
the
purpose
of
the
episode is to find out who is “Big Brother” here in the real world.
Here,
I
believe,
McGoohan
implements
a
unique
tactic.
Rather
than
perhaps
conceding
it
is
some
authoritarian
government,
which
would
appeal
to
the
majority
of
viewers
of
the
time,
he
insinuates
it
is
Society
itself
which
is
making
Prisoners
out
of
people.
Such
an
action
would
anger
viewers
because
they
are
an
example
of
Society
trying
to
force
what
they
like
on
those
at
the other end of the TV signal.
If
we
knew
who
or
what
“Number
One”
was,
we
can
probably
make
sense
of
the
rest
of
the
story.
So,
who
is
it?
It
is
Society's
demand
of
Number
Six,
that's
who.
As
director
and
producer,
the
way
in
which
to
reject
conformity
is
to
reject
the
Number
Six
character as a super-spy.
As
such,
we
see
him
blast
this
portrayal
of
himself
into
outer
space.
This
is
symbolic
of
McGoohan
rejecting
what
the
mass
viewers wanted. The freedom he granted himself was freedom from this typecast.
Was
this
rude
of
McGoohan?
Not
really.
In
fact,
one
should've
expected
this,
but
probably
most
fans
of
the
series
at
the
time
were
blinded
by
the
intricate
details
and
well-directed
scripts
of
the
first
sixteen
episodes.
Because
we
as
a
society
tried
to
idolize
No.6/McGoohan,
McGoohan
had
to
reject
this
very
hypocritical
view
of
the
Prisoner.
Sure,
the
show
initially
tried
to
portray
our
governments
molding
people,
but
having
the
TV
viewers
molding
individuals
is
just
as
bad.
The
Prisoner
had
a
new
evil
to
free
himself
from.
At
the
same
time,
McGoohan
wanted
to
teach
TV
viewers
a
lesson:
build
your
own
kingdom;
don't worship others
.
This might explain why the story is so surreal. In 48 hours, how would you
develop a script which naturally ties the old episodes of the higher powers
watching us to this new form of evil? Given the short amount of time,it is
reasonable to expect that the script would have to be surreal, “fit the facts.”
Main Characters
•
Number Six -- Patrick McGoohan, or a person affronted by public scrutiny at
the business end of the camera
•
Robed figures -- Reactionists, Patriots, Nationalists...various members together
representing the political spectrum of the world
•
the President -- an intermediary between the public and Number Six (the President of the BBC comes to mind)
•
No. 2 and No. 48 -- other people scrutinized by the public that just didn't meet their approval and have been castigated or
“labeled”
•
the Butler-- Tied in from the other sixteen episodes, he is considered below the other candidates and is not held under
scrutiny
•
Number One -- Manifestation of Society wanting a superspy celebrity such as PMcG to idolize.
Here are some instances that are solved by this theory, and the reasoning behind them:
•
The
ending
“Once
Upon
a
Time”
makes
some
sense,
if
we
were
to
assume
it
is
No.1
who
says,
“Die,
Six,
Die!”
“Once
Upon
a
Time”
was
actually
produced
much
earlier
than
right
before
“Fall
Out”;
in
fact,
it
was
one
of
the
first
six
or
seven
episodes
to
be
written.
Thus,
“Once
Upon
a
Time”
was
filmed
before
McGoohan
envisioned
who
No.1
was
going
to
be
(he
stated
this
himself
in
the
Troyer
Interview),
except
for
the
final
minutes
of
the
episode.
The
final
few
shots,
which
stretch
from
the
Swanwick
encounter
until
the
end,
were
dubbed
in
at
the
last
moment
before
it
was
released
as
the
penultimate
episode.
Assuming
that
the
“Die,
Six,
Die!”
voice
was
also
dubbed
in
(it
certainly
sounds
like
it
was!),
it
is
possible
that
the
voice
is
No.1's.
Thus,
No.1
may
have
killed
No.2
because
PMcG
thought
everyone
wanted
to
see
No.2
die.
This
is
not
what
McGoohan's real character wanted; hence, Number Six's desire to confront No. 1 in person.
•
When
No.6
gets
his
real
suit
back
on,
he's
back
to
his
“real
self”,
as
what
the
masses
wanted
to
see,
as
stated
by
the
Supervisor.
(Note
that
the
swinging
hangers
imply
the
Robed
figures
had
just
dressed
themselves.)
PMcG
takes
off
the
old
suit because he eventually wants to leave the series behind him
•
McKern
(No.2)'s
and
Kanner
(No.
48)'s
speeches
were
to
emphasize
the
fact
that
they
were
individuals,
but
their
rebellious
forms
were
not
in
good
keeping
compared
to
No.
6's
well-cultured
method
of
rebellion,
which
everyone
craved.
(No.
6
says
to
Kanner,
“Don't
wear
yourself
out,”
for
a
different
reason.
He's
simply
saying
that
we
can
rebel
against
society,
but
it
doesn't
have
to
be
to
the
point that we
destroy
society.)
•
McKern's
speech
and
act
of
rebellion
is
to
deflect
the
notion
that
it
was
the
U.K.
government
that
was
“Big
Brother”.
After
all,
even
a
man
of
Parliament
became
a
prisoner.
•
PMcG
(No.
6)
rejects
the
President
because
the
President
and
Robed
figures
represent
the
public.
Everyone
yells
“I”
No.6's
final speech because everyone only cares about “him”.
•
He
takes
the
checks
and
petty
cash
because
he
rebels
against
anything
that
the
public
wants
(he's
trying
to
show
the
viewer
that he won't stand for anything the public wants him to have.
•
An
“orbit”
module
is
sent
up
to
eventually
fetch
No.
6.
Note
that
it
is
unnumbered.
He
has
been
promoted
to
a
numberless
person,
but
is
still
held
under
check.
By
taking
the
money
and
not
the
job
of
leading
the
world,
he
has
failed
to
appease
the
masses and must be put into the same category as No.2 and No. 48.
•
Why
the
modules
have
the
name
“Orbit”
remains
largely
unsolved
by
this
theory.
However,
because
of
the
space
race
of
the
60s,
it
could
have
something
to
do
with
symbolism
of
“rocketing”
No.2
and
No.
48
from
existence.
This,
of
course,
changes
to “rocketing” No.1 and
the Prisoner
series from existence.
•
The
glass
orb,
which
No.1
holds
out
to
No.6,
is
a
symbol
of
No.1's
power.
It
seems
to
be
an
allegory
of
God
holding
the
“whole
world
in
His
hands”,
where
now
No.1
(the
image
of
PMcG
which
PMcG
is
trying
to
reject)
is
holding
the
“world”
of
worshipping
TV
viewers
who
want
to
conform
to
him.
(Note
that
you
can
see
images
in
a
glass
orb,
just
like
you
see
images
from
a
glass
TV
screen.
Also,
there
are
all
kinds
of
world
globes
in
that
room,
strengthening
the
“world
in
His
hands”
analogy.
Each
globe
appears
to
be
fixed
on
some
part
of
the
world
where
the
Prisoner
is
being
watched.)
When
No.6
takes
this
orb
and
smashes
it,
it
represents
PMcG's
desire
to
liberate
the
public
of
conforming
to
his
ideals
and
his
hope
that
they
become independent thinkers.
•
Number
One
is
wearing
an
ape
mask
because
this
symbolizes
the
many
viewers
who
are
trying
to
conform
to
PMcG's
ideals
-- who are trying to imitate him (after all, “to ape” means to imitate or mimic).
•
The
Robed
figures
look
like
members
of
the
Village
when
undressed.
This
is
to
offer
segue
from
the
first
sixteen
episodes
in
that members of the public were mixed into the Village, keeping baneful watch over their guests.
•
Rover
dies
for
the
same
reason
No.1
gets
ejected
into
space
--
everyone
saw
Rover
as
an
icon
of
the
Prisoner
,
which
made
PMcG
feel
it
distracted
the
people
from
understanding
his
ideals,
so
it
is
destroyed
at
the
end.
(He
wants
this
icon
“out
of
his
life”
as
well.)
The
song
“I-I-I...
I
like
you
very
much”
makes
a
lot
of
sense
here,
if
you
were
a
viewer
who
likes
Rover
a
lot!
•
Most
of
the
celebratory
events
going
on
in
the
truck
at
the
end
is
in
knowing
the
Prisoner
series
is
over
and
getting
rid
of
junk associated with it.
•
A
road
to
the
Village
is
the
A20.
When
Markstein
left,
McGoohan
overrode
any
possibility
of
some
concentration
camp
or
secret
base
conjured
up
in
“Many
Happy
Returns”
for
example.
By
viewing
“Fall
Out”,
the
Village
not
only
represents
a
society
of
conformers
but,
more
specifically,
the
public
trying
to
conform
to
PMcG.
PMcG
wanted
to
place
the
Village
literally
in
the
TV
viewer's
backyard.
Therefore,
the
Village
is
anywhere
and
everywhere
in
Britain
(and
maybe
even
the
world, for that matter).
•
PMcG
befriends
the
Butler,
McKern,
and
Kanner,
because
they
are
the
only
ones
who
don't
conform
to
his
ideals.
The
Butler,
in
particular,
doesn't
care
about
PMcG's
ideals;
he
just
does
his
job.
(This
was
previously
established
...
I
just
use
this
to illustrate how this theory meshes well with other theories.)
So,
we
should
not
feel
any
resentment
to
McGoohan
at
all.
It
was
our
own
blindness
that
made
Number
One
who
he
is,
not
Patrick
McGoohan's.
McGoohan
heroically
avoided
a
close
call
with
hypocrisy
--
and
it
is
an
obscure
form
of
not
giving
in.
We
can still learn from this episode that we should live with independent minds, even in a society such as today's.
Many
fans
still
wonder
whether
Number
Six
is
really
Patrick
McGoohan?
Some
believe
that
it
is
John
Drake
,
the
fictitious
star
of
Danger
Man.
All
we
can
say
is
this:
in
the
beginning
of
production
of
the
Prisoner
,
PMcG
may
have
wanted
Drake's
name
omitted
from
the
series
because
it
would
be
easier
to
write
stories
from
a
first-person
than
a
third-person
point
of
view.
(Franz
Kafka's
The
Trial
and
The
Castle
are
similar
in
this
regard
--
Kafka
originally
made
the
story
first-person,
but
later
made
it
third-
person
so
that
people
could
readily
associate
with
the
main
character
in
the
story.)
By
the
time
of
“Fall
Out”,
you
may
see
that
McGoohan has really manifested No.6 as himself!